The Supreme Court’s Dwindling Reputation

The recent string of controversial rulings and ethical allegations involving the Supreme Court have significantly eroded the trust of the American people in this esteemed institution. The fallout from the court’s most recent term, highlighted by its presidential immunity ruling, has legal experts concerned that the court’s reputation may be beyond repair.

Scathing Reviews

In a recent report by The Washington Post’s Justin Jouvenal, legal scholars were highly critical of the court’s most recent term. The justices issued far-reaching decisions that pushed the law hard to the right, while at the same time, justices were facing ethical allegations that called into question their impartiality.

A Legitimacy Problem

According to legal expert Charles Geyh of Indiana University, the court may have a potential legitimacy issue. The fundamental principle that the court’s decisions will be accepted, whether one agrees with them or not, is becoming increasingly in doubt. Geyh explains that many of the ethical allegations facing the court foster the perception that it is an organization that is more political than legal.

Reputation on Shaky Ground

Kermit Roosevelt, a law professor at the University of Pennsylvania and former clerk for Justice David Souter, believes that the court’s reputation may fall even further than it already has. The consequences of recent decisions such as the Chevron decision and the presidential immunity ruling may be felt in the future.

The Positive Side

Gabe Roth, the executive director of Fix the Court, is optimistic that the current scrutiny of the court and calls for judicial ethics reform are a step in the right direction. Roth believes that the justices of the Supreme Court should be treated like politicians when it comes to assessing their moral character and potential conflicts of interest.

Conclusion

It’s clear that the Supreme Court’s reputation has taken a significant hit in recent years. With controversial decisions and ethical allegations continually casting doubt on the impartiality of the court, it’s essential not to overlook the potential damage this could do to the American people’s trust in one of the most distinguished institutions in the nation.

Originally Post From https://www.rawstory.com/supreme-court-illegitimate/

Supreme Court at risk of rulings being ignored due to legitimacy concerns, warns legal expert